# MCP vs RAG vs NLWeb vs HTML: A Comparison of the Effectiveness and Efficiency of Different Agent Interfaces to the Web (Technical Report)

Compares HTML browsing, RAG, MCP, and NLWeb interfaces for web agents performing product search, comparison, and checkout tasks in four simulated e-shops.

- Catalog URL: https://awesomecua.com/resources/arxiv-2511-23281/
- Original source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.23281
- Kind: paper
- Review: curated
- Scope: core
- Environments: web
- Topics: evaluation, tool-integration, efficiency, web-navigation
- Evidence checked: 2026-11-05T23:02:12Z
- ID: arxiv:2511.23281

## Limitations

The annotation and scope were reviewed against the complete retained arXiv abstract (v1). The comparison uses four simulated e-shops. Experiments, reported performance and artifact availability have not been independently reproduced.

- Record JSON: https://awesomecua.com/resources/arxiv-2511-23281/record.json

## Authors

Aaron Steiner, Ralph Peeters, Christian Bizer

## Citation exports

- BibTeX: https://awesomecua.com/resources/arxiv-2511-23281/citation.bib
- CSL JSON: https://awesomecua.com/resources/arxiv-2511-23281/citation.csl.json

## Recorded arXiv snapshot

- Version: 1
- Version source: https://arxiv.org/abs/2511.23281v1
- First submission: 2025-11-28T15:32:15Z
- Version updated: 2025-11-28T15:32:15Z
- Abstract SHA-256: 324dc1d610b3eef0712522ac69dbf799028199d30801bebf8b89870ee2b31989
- Abstract hash normalization: sha256-utf8-whitespace-collapsed-v1

## License declarations

- code: not recorded
- data: not recorded
- document: not recorded
- weights: not recorded

## Primary evidence

- https://export.arxiv.org/api/query?id_list=2509.22644%2C2510.00078%2C2510.00507%2C2510.02608%2C2510.04536%2C2510.04791%2C2510.05137%2C2510.10049%2C2510.10991%2C2510.14308%2C2510.14545%2C2510.16720%2C2510.19838%2C2510.20707%2C2510.22102%2C2510.24284%2C2510.26098%2C2511.02805%2C2511.03628%2C2511.03773%2C2511.04707%2C2511.08325%2C2511.09309%2C2511.19957%2C2511.21631%2C2511.23281%2C2512.06641%2C2512.09458%2C2512.11506%2C2512.20237%2C2512.21481%2C2512.23646%2C2601.04203%2C2601.09668%2C2601.10611%2C2601.19923%2C2601.22352%2C2601.22770%2C2602.06485%2C2602.10863%2C2602.16165%2C2602.22897%2C2603.01104%2C2603.03296%2C2603.05294%2C2603.07915%2C2603.23526%2C2603.25764%2C2604.05015%2C2604.09718&max_results=50 (retrieved 2026-11-05T21:14:07Z; SHA-256 410a4c48b9605a531d3e6008c561ce3e3e9d92609168f5d49fadc04f5f943289)
- https://export.arxiv.org/api/query?id_list=2511.03690%2C2511.03773%2C2511.04220%2C2511.04359%2C2511.04481%2C2511.04707%2C2511.05797%2C2511.06251%2C2511.08319%2C2511.08325%2C2511.08487%2C2511.09309%2C2511.10110%2C2511.11332%2C2511.12000%2C2511.13091%2C2511.13725%2C2511.14210%2C2511.14945%2C2511.15705%2C2511.16842%2C2511.17649%2C2511.17775%2C2511.18423%2C2511.19496%2C2511.19516%2C2511.19957%2C2511.20597%2C2511.20636%2C2511.21631%2C2511.21990%2C2511.22074%2C2511.23281%2C2512.04302%2C2512.04529%2C2512.06574%2C2512.06641%2C2512.06726%2C2512.06866%2C2512.07287%2C2512.08417%2C2512.08769%2C2512.09458%2C2512.11002%2C2512.11506%2C2512.12692%2C2512.12730%2C2512.12818%2C2512.13159%2C2512.13564&max_results=50 (retrieved 2026-11-05T23:02:12Z; SHA-256 20bdf96426e8120a0cbfdbebadfabbbd4cda26d2d35ab670885f58b35ea35d5d)